best mattress buyers guide

A good mattress can make all the difference in your health. After all, great sleep quality and choosing the best mattress is one of the biggest factors when it comes to reducing stress, preventing disease, and increasing your energy levels. If you aren’t comfortable while you sleep, you’ll likely wake up feeling crabby and exhausted.

However, with so many different mattresses on the market, it can be very difficult to choose one that is a perfect fit for you. That’s why we’ve put together this mattress buyer’s guide, to help you compare the various types of available at every price point, and make the best decision about your new mattress purchase.

Major Factors when Buying a Mattress

When starting to look for a new mattress to purchase, there are many different factors you should consider. These can help you narrow down which specific mattress you want. These factors include:

Thickness

Mattresses come in a few different standard thicknesses. In general, thicker mattresses feel softer and provide more support for most people. If you weigh more than average, you are likely going to want a thicker mattress to provide even more support for your neck and spine while you are sleeping.

This is also something that is very important to think about for people who experience pain in their neck, shoulders, and back. A thin mattress will likely not provide enough support for your body to keep you comfortable.

They generally range in thickness from five inches to 20 inches. The standard thickness is usually between 10 and 14 inches. Memory foam mattresses tend to be thinner, with many models under 10 inches, while heavy coil spring mattresses are the ones that are usually the thickest, at well above 15 inches. Ultimately, the mattress thickness you choose is a matter of personal preference.

If you love a soft, supportive sleeping surface, you will likely want to opt for a thicker mattress model, while if you prefer something firmer, you may want to go with a slimmer alternative. You may also want to consider your living situation when making a purchase. Thick mattresses are heavy and difficult to move, so if you aren’t completely settled, you may want to opt for a thinner mattress for now.

Density

Density generally refers to the level of firmness in your mattress. This is most important to consider if you opt to go with a memory foam mattress, as these are the mattresses where density can vary most widely from product to product. Density is usually conveyed in pounds per cubic foot when discussing the specs of a mattress.

Very dense mattresses will feel more firm to the touch, and they will also weigh more. Preferred mattress density varies widely from person to person. The best way to assess the density of any mattress that you are considering is to go and feel it in-store to see if you would be comfortable on it.

Memory foam mattresses are marketed in three density categories: low, medium, and high.

  • Low-density are under three pounds per cubic foot and are generally designed for affordability.
  • Medium-density are the most common, at about five pounds per cubic foot, and provide a nice balance between softness and support.
  • High-density are above six pounds per cubic foot, and they are designed for ultimate support. However, they are also usually very expensive. To some people, a high-density mattress can actually feel a bit too stiff.

Ventilation and Airflow

A factor that many people overlook is the level of natural ventilation. Many mattresses are designed for good airflow, while others can tend to hold on to water and dust that passes through it over time.

We actually lose a huge amount of our body’s moisture while we sleep, which means that if your mattress does not have good ventilation, it will become very unhygienic over time, and may also start to hold on to odors as well. With particularly bad ventilation systems, you may even develop a problem with mold in your mattress.

When you are shopping for mattresses, be sure to ask about the ventilation system. Generally, higher quality mattresses have better airflow. However, there are many things you can do with any mattress to increase ventilation.

You should definitely take note of these tips if you live in a humid climate, as this is where these problems are more likely to develop. One of the most important is to mount your bed on a frame that has slats on the bottom. This allows the mattress to breathe properly.

If it is particularly muggy where you live, you could even consider turning over your mattress once a week to increase airflow.

Warranty

Since you are making such a big investment, you will definitely want to make sure that yours has a good warranty. Although you may not think you need a warranty at first, they are a lifesaver if any unexpected damage happens to your purchase.

Warranties will cover things like springs popping out, seams ripping, or other major unexpected events that result from bad manufacturing. However, consumers should be aware that warranties do not cover your personal views on the mattress. For example, you can’t use the warranty on a mattress just because you don’t think it’s comfortable.

You should also be aware that your mattress will likely not last for the entire length of your warranty. However, this figure is still a good rough indicator of its relative lifespan. For example, a ten-year warranty will likely last about twice as long as one with a five-year warranty.

Some warranties have prorated periods, which means that after a certain point, you would need to pay an out-of-pocket cost to have your mattress repaired under the warranty. Good warranties are most important for high-cost mattresses since they are such a big investment.

Top Mattress Brands

There are a variety of different mattress brands on the market right now, and each has their own pros and cons. Certain brands are known for producing specific types of mattresses, while others have a broader selection of products.

Some of the largest and most prominent brands of mattress manufacturers include Sealy, Serta, and Denver Mattress. Each of these companies makes several different types of mattresses that are aimed at specific needs, such as orthopedic mattresses, memory foam mattresses, spring mattresses, and budget mattresses.

There are also several specialty mattress brands that offer a smaller selection of high-quality mattresses. For example, the brands Casper and Tuft & Needle offer only one mattress each, but they are very highly rated and are engineered for high levels of comfort. Tempur-Pedic is another popular specialty brand, with a selection of mattresses that are designed specifically for extra comfort and health benefits.

Another unique specialty brand is Sleep Number, which provides adjustable firmness for multiple uses. This brand is a particularly popular choice among couples. Some of these brands are easily accessible in chain stores, while others need to be ordered online.

Spring vs. Foam Mattresses

There are two major types of mattresses on the market: spring mattresses and foam mattresses. Both are very popular and have their pros and cons, and which one you choose is a matter of personal preference. Spring mattresses are supported by small metal coils, which give the mattress some bounce. They usually include a pillow top supporting the body as well to provide more comfort.

Alternatively, foam and memory foam mattresses are designed to mold to the body a bit more to provide more support for the spine. These are the types of mattresses that are usually recommended to people with neck and back problems because they relieve pressure points that are sometimes put on the body by spring mattresses.

However, they are more expensive to make, which means that they are more expensive to purchase as well. Some retailers make models that combine the two options – a spring base with memory foam padding on top, designed so that you can enjoy the benefits of memory foam affordably.

Shopping for a New Mattress

There are many different places where you can buy a mattress. Where you end up purchasing your mattress will relate to its convenience factor for you, as well as the brand of mattress you end up choosing. Some mattress brands are readily available at several retailers around the country, while others are only available online or through the brand’s showrooms.

One of the first and most common places to buy a mattress is from a big box store, such as Walmart, Sears, Target, Costco, and more. The benefits of doing your shopping here are that these stores are very convenient. There is often one in driving distance of even the smallest towns.

They also tend to have very inexpensive mattress models, perfect for people on a budget, such as college students or young professionals. However, you likely won’t find the same quality of mattress at a big box store that you would elsewhere.

The next place to look for a mattress is a department store, such as Macy’s or JCPenny. These stores also provide the benefit of being relatively accessible, but they tend to have a higher selection of mattresses than a big box store. The mattress displays in these types of stores are usually larger than in big box stores, so you can lay down and really get to know what you are buying before you make a purchase.

You also might try heading to a mattress specialty store, such as Denver Mattress, Mattress Firm, or a local store. These stores are often your best bet if you want to find a truly high-quality mattress. They carry the biggest range of brands, and you can test and compare them in-store with help from associates who are knowledgeable about mattresses. However, not every town has a mattress specialty store, making this a difficult option for some consumers.

Finally, you may opt to buy a mattress online. The benefit of doing this is that you have access to a much broader range of products than you would by shopping in a physical store, and you can have items shipped to you from around the world. However, when shopping online, you don’t get to test out the mattress before you buy, so you’ll likely be relying very heavily on reviews.

A good solution to this problem is to see if an online brand has a showroom near you. You can go test out the mattress, but you don’t have to deal with the hassle of getting it home since it will be shipped to you.

Many mattress companies are now opting for online-only sales models, and they offer home trials so you can test out the product. This allows them to lower their prices, since they don’t have to go through a manufacturer, and the delivery is easier for the consumer as well.

The Different Types of Mattresses

There are a few different types of mattresses that you will encounter while doing your shopping. We’ve already discussed them briefly, but here we’ll go into more detail about what each type of mattress offers and their pros and cons.

The first and most common type of mattress is an innerspring mattress. This type of mattress contains small metal coils that give it a springy feeling. They have a pillow-like padding over the top to provide comfort. The biggest benefit of an innerspring mattress is that they are relatively inexpensive to make and purchase. They also can be very comfortable when designed well.

They are widely accessible, and there is a huge range of models to choose from, so you can select one that matches your firmness preferences. However, these mattresses often aren’t the most durable, and over time, many people find that they become less comfortable and can even put stress on their body.

Some models can also be noisy, and if you sleep with a partner, they may feel you moving during the night. Innerspring mattresses are a good choice for the general population, especially those on a budget, but should probably be avoided by those with spinal issues that need extremely good support.

The next common type of mattress is a memory foam mattress. These mattresses are created to contour to your body as you sleep, which is extremely comfortable and puts very little pressure on your body. They are usually the go-to choice for those with back and neck pain.

They are very quiet as well, and just like innerspring mattresses, they come in different densities for varied firmness. They also come in latex varieties, which many people consider to be more eco-friendly. However, these mattresses can be very expensive, especially orthopedic versions. They also can be very heavy and difficult to move on, particularly in high-density models.

Some people also notice that they retain heat, so many brands now offer gel versions, which keep them cool. They can have some issues with off-gassing right after purchase, so they should be aired out if this is a concern for you.

Many brands are now selling hybrid mattresses, which combine an innerspring base with a memory foam top for a combination of support. These mattresses are a great way to get the conforming aspects of a memory foam mattress with the firmness and bounce of an innerspring version. They can be more difficult to find than their counterparts, however, and they can also be expensive. Some models can also be very heavy because of the way they combine materials.

Memory Foam Mattresses

Memory foam mattresses have become the product of choice for many people, and there are now many different types and brands on the market. Several of these brands and models cater to consumers with specific orthopedic needs to encourage more comfortable and pain-free sleeping habits. Memory foam mattresses should be tested before purchase, as they come in many different densities to cater to various preferences.

Most memory foam mattresses are constructed from the original memory foam material, which is made from petroleum. These are very durable and come in a variety of different densities and sizes. This type of memory foam is also used in hybrid mattresses to provide extra support over the springs. The biggest problem that many people encounter with this type of material is that it can feel very hot at night.

To address the problem with heat that many of these mattresses have, many brands are starting to create gel-infused memory foam mattresses. These combine the traditional petroleum-based material with a cooling gel that is placed throughout the mattress.

Some of the most visible brands of these types of mattresses include Serta iGel, Sleep Innovations, and DreamFoam, although there are many more to choose from. They are also slightly less likely to sink than traditional memory foam, so you can move around more easily on the mattress.

Some brands also make a version of these mattresses called air cool memory foam. The layers in the mattress are designed for ventilation, so that as you sleep, the mattress will breathe and adjust to your body temperature. Many of these use an open cell design, which distributes both heat and body weight more evenly on the mattress, which feels cooler and lighter as you sleep.

Another big concern with memory foam mattresses is that they are not eco-friendly because they are made from petroleum. The traditional memory foam material can have an off-putting smell upon initial purchase, and they can also release chemicals from the petroleum during sleep, which is called off-gassing.

To combat this, many companies have started creating plant-based memory foam mattresses. These mattresses reduce chemical output, and many of them are also designed to minimize heat retention as well.

An offshoot of the memory foam trend is latex foam. Latex foam feels very similar to memory foam, but since it contains latex, it has a unique bounce to it that helps the mattress feel more like a spring mattress and prevent sagging over time.

Latex also tends to be cooler than traditional memory foam, which is a benefit that many people value highly. Many brands are now starting to include a layer of latex foam on top of their memory foam mattresses to give their customers the benefits of both types of foam.

Sleepedia Mattress Buying Guide

We've taken the best of the best in each category to aid your buying decision and ensure you get the very best for your budget. Simply use the buttons below to jump to the relevant section.

CHOOSE YOUR BUDGET

How Much Should You Spend On A Mattress?

There are mattresses available at every price point, from low-budget to complete luxury. At every price point, there are great products and ones that are probably worth a pass. Later on, we’ll cover our favorite mattresses at several different price points to help you decide.

However, when setting a budget, it helps to have an idea of exactly what you can expect from each different price point of mattresses.

Price Ranges

$200 - $400$400 - $600$600 - $1000$1000 - $1500$1500 - $2500$2500 - $5000$5000+

These mattresses are specifically designed for people on a budget. They usually need to be purchased online, although there are a few in-store options available if you do some dedicated searching. Both memory foam and spring options are available at this price point.

These mattresses are usually not very thick when compared to their more expensive counterparts. Most models also aren’t likely to last more than a few years, and many either don’t have warranties or have very short warranties (five years or less).

This category is still on the low end for mattresses, but provides a bit more quality and reliability. They will have better construction and engineering than the previous category, but might still not use the most durable materials.

This category is likely to have a longer warranty on it as well. Many people purchase these mattresses for child use, or for their guest bedrooms.

These mid-range mattresses provide a good compromise between quality and price. They are usually the most accessible, with many mattresses in department and box stores priced in this category. They are also available in a wider range of materials and usually, have solid warranties.

This category starts to transition into investment mattresses instead of low-use ones. These mattresses usually have more features and are designed for comfort and durability.

They have long warranties of over ten years, and they provide good customer satisfaction. They are available in mattress specialty stores and some department stores.

These mattresses are decidedly high-priced. They have special features for health and comfort and are designed to be extremely durable and last for years to come.

They are expertly crafted for ventilation and desired firmness. Many mattress products in this range are niche brands, which are often only available online or in specific showrooms.

This category contains extremely luxurious mattresses, many of which come in large sizes and densities. They are built to last for decades, and they include special features for comfort and health, just as in the last category.

They use the best materials and often combine different construction techniques for an ideal combination of support. Many of these mattresses also offer customizable features.

In this category, you can expect the highest quality mattresses on the market. They will likely be queen or king size, and they will use the best materials available for ultimate comfort.

These mattresses aren’t typically sold by brands you’d find in department stores – you’ll have to head to a specialty retailer or look online. Again, mattresses at this price range often come with custom features.

Best Mattresses Under $500

Dreamfoam Bedding Spring Dreams

8/10

Comfort:

7/10

Pain Relief:

8/10

Durability:

8/10

Warranty:

10/10

Price:

8/10

Overall Score:

This traditional coil mattress contains 660 coils. It has a layer of quilting and thin foam over the top for comfort. It has a ten-year warranty. The full size is 54” x 74”, and the product weighs 61 pounds. The mattress is double sided, so it can be flipped for durability and longevity.

If you prefer the firm feel of a spring mattress to memory foam, and you’re looking for an affordable option, this is by far the best purchase for you. Since it has so many coils, it reduces the feeling of pressure that can often happen with spring mattresses.

This also reduces motion transfer, which is a concern for those who sleep with their partner. If you shift around in your sleep, you won’t feel that bouncing, reverberating motion that is so common with spring mattresses.

The mattress comes compressed into a 15” x 15” x 56” box. This makes it easier to ship and move between rooms. It is also designed to be used on both sides, which makes it more durable and prevents sagging. Many reviewers also love the fact that it does not make noise, another common problem with innerspring mattresses.

It also looks and feels more expensive than it is, and provides enough support for those with back pain. It is relatively durable for the price, lasting roughly five years or more in many cases, and the customer service for the company is good, so you can trust the warranty. It is a great option for those needing a new mattress quickly and at a good price.

Resort Sleep Queen Cool Memory Foam Mattress

10/10

Comfort:

9/10

Pain Relief:

6/10

Durability:

8/10

Warranty:

10/10

Price:

8.5/10

Overall Score:

This product is 80 x 60 x 10 inches. It weighs 65 pounds. It has a layer of 2.5 inches of Premium Air Infused Visco Elastic Foam, layered on top of a high-density foam base. It contains cooling technology, and it is environmentally friendly and hypoallergenic. The product also comes with a removable, washable case, as well as a memory foam pillow. It has a 20-year limited warranty.

This mattress provides mind-blowing value for money. It is designed for incredible comfort as

the base of the mattress is made from dense, supportive foam, it reduces the pressure on your spine, making for a healthier sleep. In particular, it is designed to target sore hips and shoulders.

It is also one of the only inexpensive mattresses designed to be so environmentally friendly. It contains a very minimal amount of toxins because the mattress is constructed in a climate controlled environment.

The fabric is specifically designed to be antimicrobial and resistant to dust mites, which helps prevent illness and skin irritation as you sleep. Since the fabric is removable and washable, it also keeps you healthy no matter how long you use the mattress.

This mattress comes compressed and rolled up, which makes it easy to move. The mattress is well-loved by consumers for its extremely comfortable feel. Many even use it as a cheap option for treating chronic back pain. Since it is environmentally friendly, there is no unpleasant odor and you can sleep on it right away without having to air it out. The durability level is average, but with such a great price, it’s still worth the investment.

Signature Sleep Contour 8-Inch Mattress

9/10

Comfort:

7/10

Pain Relief:

7/10

Durability:

4/10

Warranty:

10/10

Price:

7.5/10

Overall Score:

 

This product is 60 x 80 x 8 inches. It weighs 45 pounds. It contains CertiPUR-US certified foam in layers at the top and bottom of the mattress, and 7”, 15 gauge coils in the middle. The foam has very low emissions and is made with no flame retardants.

This hybrid mattress provides comfort for an incredible price. The combination of the coils and the memory foam provide a firm feeling, while the memory foam ensures good weight distribution and takes the pressure off of your joints.

It is also relatively durable compared to other mattresses of this price point. This mattress is a great choice for those who want a firm mattress but need the structural support that memory foam provides. However, purchasers should be aware that it only comes with a one-year limited warranty.

This mattress is only eight inches tall, which makes it easy to transport if you need to move. It comes in a duffel package as well, so all you need to do is unroll it when it arrives. The combination of the springs and the memory foam reduces noise and makes it easier to move as well.

The mattress is available on Amazon as well as the Walmart website, so it is very accessible. It receives rave reviews for its comfortable feel, great price, and convenient packaging. It is a popular choice among college students and recent graduates, and it also works very well as a kid’s bed.

Best Mattress Under $750

Sealy Posturepedic Chaleigh

9/10

Comfort:

6/10

Pain Relief:

9/10

Durability:

8/10

Warranty:

9/10

Price:

8/10

Overall Score:

 

A queen size in this mattress is 12.5” x 60” x 80”. All mattresses in this style are 12.5 inches high. They contain the Sealy Embrace Coil system and are covered with a very thin layer of foam and plush padding. The quilting also contains flame guard fiber. The mattress has a 10-year non-prorated warranty.

The Sealy Posturepedic line is known for providing great innerspring mattresses at reasonable prices. The Chaleigh model, in particular, has very reasonable prices. These mattresses are designed for firmness and support with Sealy’s traditional coil systems.

In particular, this product is known for isolating motion. If you sleep with a partner, you can move around during the night without the mattress reacting. The mattress also works well no matter what position you sleep in.

For the most part, the Sealy Posturepedic mattresses are designed for high durability. The fabric is knit and is created to prevent fraying. The coils are also individually wrapped to provide even support throughout the bed and to prevent sagging as well.

Although the mattress is designed to be firm, many users say that it feels very soft and comfortable. In general, these mattresses last between five and ten years. The warranty also covers sagging for dents over 1.5 inches, something that helps many users feel at ease with their new mattress.

Gel Memory Foam by Exceptional Sheets

9/10

Comfort:

7/10

Pain Relief:

6/10

Durability:

10/10

Warranty:

9/10

Price:

8/10

Overall Score:

 

This mattress is 40.5” x 21.3” x 20.3”, and weighs 75 pounds. It has a seven inch base of 1.8-pound high-density foam and then is topped with three inches of 3-pound gel density memory foam for cooling and contouring. It is vacuum-sealed and compressed for delivery. It comes with a 120-night trial, as well as a 10-year full coverage warranty.

If you are looking for a memory foam mattress that keeps cool and dry even in the most humid climates, this is an amazing choice for you. The gel top layer is infused with small cooling particles, which direct air flow to keep you from feeling overheated at night.

The base foam is designed to provide support for the back and neck while you sleep. The mattress contours to your body to keep you comfortable.

The mattress is also CertiPUR-US certified for environmentally conscious production, with very minimal odors right after purchase that disappears quickly. It also has a zipper cover that is removable and machine washable, which helps prevent illness and irritation of the skin.

It comes packaged in a compressed box and expands quickly. In terms of texture, it is quite soft and does experience some compression over time.

However, it doesn’t create an uncomfortable sinking feeling during sleep, and it springs back to its original shape very quickly after compression. One of the things that appeal to many people about this mattress is the trial period and warranty.

The trial period is a full four months, and the warranty covers much more damage than average. The company is also owned by veterans and donates one out of every 45 mattresses that they sell to charity.

Tuft & Needle Mattress

10/10

Comfort:

10/10

Pain Relief:

7/10

Durability:

7/10

Warranty:

9/10

Price:

8.5/10

Overall Score:

 

This mattress contains two layers of high-density foam. It has a 7-inch base layer that is designed for support and alignment and a 3-inch comfort layer that is designed for cooling and has bounce for easy movement. The mattress is certified by CertiPUR-US, and the cover is also chemical free. It is 10 x 60 x 80 inches and weighs 78.1 pounds.

Although this isn’t technically a hybrid mattress, we thought it fit the bill for this category because it provides many of the same benefits that hybrid mattresses do.

The Tuft & Needle brand was created specifically to address problems that consumers have with both spring and memory foam mattresses, so it has a dense, supportive core to reduce pain, but the top layer is soft and bouncy for easy movement and comfort while sleeping. It is also designed to keep the body cool during the night.

The top layer is infused not only with gel but also graphite to keep temperatures under control as you sleep.

This mattress is highly rated by customers online, who enjoy this unique combination of great mattress features. The foam is actually patented because of the way it bounces back. Many memory foam mattresses result in sinking or sagging over time, but the Tuft & Needle mattress is intended to feel like a spring mattress but without the noise or the pain.

It is considered to be on the softer side, so it isn’t the most durable of mattresses. It lasts roughly five years. It is also only sold online through the company – it is not sold in showrooms.

This is why the price is relatively low too. The product also has a standard ten-year warranty, and the company also offers thirty-day trials if desired.

Best Mattresses Under $1,000

Saatva Mattress

9/10

Comfort:

8/10

Pain Relief:

10/10

Durability:

10/10

Warranty:

8/10

Price:

8/10

Overall Score:

 

The Saatva comes in two thicknesses, 14.5” and 11.5”. It has two layers of coils for firm support. The bottom layer consists of interconnected hourglass-shaped coils, while the top layer contains larger, individually wrapped coils. These layers are then covered with a premium pillow top.

Saatva offers three different comfort levels, ranging from plush soft to extra firm. All of the materials in the Saatva mattress are completely eco-friendly, and the mattress comes with a 75-day trial as well. It also has a 15-year non-prorated warranty.

Saatva is a unique mattress brand that combines the traditional innerspring mattress with modern design and eco-friendly materials. Like several of the other popular brands on this list, they only sell their mattresses online. They offer national delivery and installation, so you don’t have to worry about transporting the mattress, which is larger than average to accommodate the spring technology.

You can choose between three different levels of firmness. A customizable mattress for that price would be unheard of in a department store. Although you cannot try the mattress in-store, the 75-day trial allows you to test it at home to make sure you like it.

While many spring mattresses are known for causing joint pain over time, the Saatva mattress combines two different coiling systems to reduce pressure points. The bottom support layer is made with very small coil units that are tempered and oven-baked for good quality, and they ensure that the mattress feels firm and comfortable.

The individually wrapped coils eliminate motion transfer during the night and are designed to react to the shape and movement of your body for comfort. One of the other amazing things about the Saatva mattress is its durability. It is designed to last over ten years and has a 15-year warranty to match.

Casper Sleep Mattress

8/10

Comfort:

10/10

Pain Relief:

10/10

Durability:

8/10

Warranty:

8/10

Price:

9/10

Overall Score:

 

This mattress contains four layers of memory foam and latex foam. The latex is open cell and hypoallergenic. Like many other popular new mattresses, it ships in a box and comes with a traditional 10-year warranty. A queen is a standard 80 x 60 x 10, and it weighs 88 pounds.

Casper makes just one model of mattress, but they have perfected this innovative design since they came on the scene in 2014. Their mattresses are sold online only, and they come compressed and rolled up in a small box. The mattress is designed specifically to be comfortable for all types of sleepers, whether you sleep on your side, back, or stomach.

The memory foam in the mattress is dense, which provides support for your spine and joints to prevent pain. However, the latex foam provides a unique bounce to the mattress that makes it easy and comfortable to move on and prevents sagging. Casper was one of the first brands to combine latex and memory foam with their products, and they still outdo the competition.

Because Casper is only sold online, it is cheaper than many other mattresses of its caliber. It has a unique feeling that combines the firmness of a spring mattress with the plush feeling of a latex mattress. Because of this, it works well for both large and small users, and it is very durable. Many people like it because it minimizes back pain but still feels firm, which many mattresses are not able to do.

Helix Mattress

8/10

Comfort:

10/10

Pain Relief:

8/10

Durability:

7/10

Warranty:

9/10

Price:

9/10

Overall Score:

 

The Helix company offers a customizable mattress that you can adjust to your preferred level of firmness. Upon ordering, you answer a quick quiz, and then your bed is custom-made and shipped to you in about one week in a compressed box. The mattress has 2.5 inches of latex foam on top, a 1.5-inch layer of micro coils, and a base layer of poly foam. The mattress comes with a 100-day trial period and a 10-year warranty.

Helix is one of the most innovative mattress companies on the market, allowing you to order a completely unique mattress online. The mattresses are made from a combination of foam and micro coils, so you get the benefits of both spring and memory foam mattresses. You’ll also get the unique bounce that latex foam provides, which minimizes sagging and makes it easier to move on your mattress. Helix consults with doctors when designing their mattresses, so they are highly recommended for those with joint pain. Although the Helix mattresses provide many of the features of luxury mattresses.

When you take the Helix mattress quiz, you will be asked about your height and weight, your firmness and support preferences, and the level of temperature regulation that you need. You can also include details about any health needs you may have. This will be the starting point to help you create your unique mattress.

Couples can even create a mattress that has dual comfort options, so both users can sleep happily without sacrificing the other’s comfort. This also reduces motion transfer, so you won’t feel your partner moving around on their side of the bed.

The Helix mattress ships in a box and takes a few days to decompress, but after that, it retains its shape nicely and is built to be very durable. Their 100-day trial period is very generous for an online company, and they have a standard 10-year warranty as well.

Best Mattresses Under $1,500

King Koil Kensington Plush

9/10

Comfort:

9/10

Pain Relief:

5/10

Durability:

8/10

Warranty:

8/10

Price:

7.5/10

Overall Score:

 

This mattress has 630 individually wrapped coils for support and has a silk and wool quilted padding over the top. The mattress also uses latex gel and Visco memory foam for cooling and support. It has an edge foam encasement to keep the mattress structured. It has a height of 16”. It comes with a natural wood foundation as a base for the mattress. It has a standard 10-year non-prorated warranty.

This classic coil mattress evokes hotel quality comfort with its thick, soft feeling. It contains a base foam and then has a thick layer of individually wrapped coils for a feeling that is soft yet supported. The top quilting layer contains performance foam as well as gel inserts, which make the mattress feel even softer and relieves pressure points, while also keeping you cool.

King Koil makes a huge variety of mattresses at varying price points, but this one provides great comfort and is a luxury investment piece that is still within the price range for many people. Out of their range, this is one of their softest mattresses. They have many other models for those who prefer a firmer mattress.

King Koil is a particularly good choice for those who tend to sleep hot and want a mattress that will help regulate their temperature. Because these mattresses contain minimal foam and they also have gel inserts, they won’t hold on to heat and humidity that can be overwhelming in the summer.

They also don’t have an unpleasant odor or release chemicals into the environment. These mattresses are widely available in mattress stores, particularly in the eastern part of the US, and some models can also be ordered online as well. They have a standard 10-year warranty. The biggest downside is that the mattress isn’t as durable as other similar models because it is so soft and plush.

Amerisleep Revere 12”

9/10

Comfort:

9/10

Pain Relief:

10/10

Durability:

10/10

Warranty:

7/10

Price:

9/10

Overall Score:

 

The mattress contains seven inches of BioCore support foam as a base, with three inches of BioPurTM cooling memory foam for comfort on top. The cover is infused with Celliant, which is designed to help you fall asleep more quickly.

All Amerisleep mattresses are made in America with natural materials, and they don’t contain the same harmful chemicals that many memory foam mattresses do. They are made with VPF technology, which minimizes chemicals and gives the mattress more room to breathe. It has a 20-year warranty and a 90-day trial period.

Amerisleep is known for creating quality memory foam mattresses that appeal to eco-conscious consumers. The Revere provides the best bang for your buck, with a good combination of premium features and relative affordability.

This mattress is designed to be medium firm, which is the most versatile firmness for most sleepers. However, the top comfort layer keeps it from feeling too hard. Because of the high-quality memory foam, there is very little motion transfer during the night.

One of the unique things about Amerisleep mattresses is that they infuse Celliant into the covers of their mattresses. This is a custom blend of minerals that react to the heat of your body and turn it into infrared light. This actually increases your blood and oxygen flow as you sleep, which helps minimize pain and cramping.

This helps many people fall asleep more quickly and stay cool during the night as well. The Revere mattress also has a great warranty of 20 years, designed to reflect the durable design of Amerisleep products. Although Amerisleep products can only be purchased online, they do come with a 90-day trial period, so you can decide whether or not you love it before making a financial commitment.

Beautyrest Recharge World Class Manorville Mattress

10/10

Comfort:

10/10

Pain Relief:

10/10

Durability:

9/10

Warranty:

8/10

Price:

9/10

Overall Score:

 

This mattress features a 1000-coil density of Beautyrest’s pocket coil technology as well as AirCool Memory Foam with GelTouch to keep you comfortable and supported throughout the night. It also has TruTemp technology as well as a mesh border to help the mattress breathe and stay cool throughout the night. It is 13.5” tall at the center and 11” tall at the border. It has a 25-year warranty. A King size is 192.3 pounds, and measures 79.5 x 76 x 23 inches when shipped.

This mattress has all the benefits of a classic coil mattress, but with updated technology to help keep your body healthy while you sleep. It has a layer of individually wrapped and pocketed coils at the base, which keeps the mattress firm and prevents sagging over the years.

It then has several layers of memory foam as well as gel inserts to conform to the body and keep you cool while you sleep. It also comes with a box spring for the foundation. It is designed specifically for longevity, with a stunning 25-year warranty, as well as Beautyrest’s Transflexion Technology, which ensures that the mattress feels the same when you buy it as it does for years to come.

Many users have applauded this mattress for it’s luxurious and light feel. It is very supportive without feeling too firm, which is a plus for many people who have trouble sleeping or are picky with their mattresses.

The foam is designed to return to its shape after sleep, but it is soft enough to eliminate the bouncy feeling that is common with many mattress brands. Although this is definitely an investment piece, it is actually cheaper than many comparable models from other brands.

Best Mattresses Under $2,500

Sterling Sleep Hospitality Imperial 5 Diamond

9/10

Comfort:

8/10

Pain Relief:

10/10

Durability:

7/10

Warranty:

7/10

Price:

8/10

Overall Score:

 

The mattress has a coil count of 744 and dimensions of 60 x 80 x 12 inches. It contains 6” of fabric encased coils with a foam comfort layer over the top that is replaceable. It also comes with a foam and coil encasement for additional support, which can be easily removed for cleaning. It is made using replaceable components and recycled content and has antimicrobial protection. It has a ten-year warranty.

This unique luxury mattress is designed for both comfort and sustainability. It is a great choice for the modern customer who doesn’t want to sacrifice comfort and quality to be environmentally friendly.

The solid 6” base provides a firm support throughout the night, and the foam encasement provides comfort and structure to help prevent sagging and keep the bed lasting longer. The foam comfort layer on top is actually replaceable as well, so you can change it out after a few years for a fresh new one.

The construction of the mattress is completely sustainable, and it uses recycled materials and an eco-friendly manufacturing process. The fabrics and materials used are specifically created to be antimicrobial and antibacterial to prevent illness.

Since the parts of the mattress are removable and replaceable, you can actually clean the inside of the mattress, which is something that is unheard of with other models. This also makes the mattress last much longer because you can contact the company for replacement parts if one starts to go bad.

Although a queen, the price somewhat pays for itself over the years, because you’ll only have to invest in new parts and not a whole new mattress. The warranty is a standard ten-year warranty. Unfortunately, the mattresses are only available in their store in California or online, so this may be a turnoff for some.

DynastyMattress Split CalKing Memory Foam Mattress

10/10

Comfort:

10/10

Pain Relief:

8/10

Durability:

9/10

Warranty:

8/10

Price:

9/10

Overall Score:

 

This mattress set comes in a split California King setup and is 12 inches thick. In total, the set is 84 x 72 x 25 inches with the accompanying base. It has a 5” support foam base, 4” of Cool AirFlow foam, and 3” of HD memory foam for comfort.

It also comes with 2 gel memory foam pillows. The mattress is adjustable and comes with massage settings. They provide curbside delivery and vacuum-seal the mattresses for convenience. It has a 20-year warranty.

This luxury mattress provides many of the features of higher-end luxury brands at a lower price. Although by no means inexpensive, it is actually thousands of dollars cheaper than many comparable models.

It comes in a split California King size, so you and your partner each have your own adjustable sides of the bed. You can adjust the position of the mattress to support you while you are sitting and sleeping with a remote control, which is included. The mattress also comes with massage functions for the ultimate in luxury.

The gel memory foam in this mattress is designed to keep you cool while you sleep, and the comfort layer at the top really conforms to your body, which is a plus for all types of sleepers. It also comes with two gel memory foam pillows to keep your neck and head supported and cool while you sleep. The mattress is on the firm side, which really provides the support you need and prevents sagging. The product has an extensive

The mattress is on the firm side, which really provides the support you need and prevents sagging. The product has an extensive 20-year warranty, which is double the industry standard. Since the units are very heavy, it comes delivered directly to you, which is a huge plus.

Stearns and Foster Lux Estate Mattress

10/10

Comfort:

9/10

Pain Relief:

6/10

Durability:

7/10

Warranty:

7/10

Price:

10/10

Overall Score:

 

This mattress uses PrimaCool performance fabric as a liner and contains high-quality memory foam layers on top of an intricately designed coil base. It has a PrecisionEdge system that keeps the mattress structured and prevents sagging. It also has an AirCool ventilation system to regulate temperature. The Stearns and Foster brand offers a standard 10-year warranty on their products.

Stearns and Foster is a highly luxurious mattress brand, perfect for those who want their home to feel like a resort every day. They are known for their elegant look and use of quality materials. They also feel very impressive to the touch, with several layers of memory foam on top to create the plush feel that is desired by many. One of the best things about this mattress is the way it conforms to your body, something that is not often found in many hybrid or innerspring mattresses.

The coils are actually designed to move with your body throughout the night, which relieves pressure points and keeps you feeling supported. A particularly interesting feature of this mattress is the motion separation seam, which means that if you sleep with a partner, the seam will absorb your movements so they can stay asleep.

Since Stearns and Foster is a very high-quality brand, they offer many customization options, so that you can choose a firmness that works well for you and your needs. In general, their mattresses run on the firmer side to provide more support, which is appreciated by many but may not be a great choice for everyone.

The top of all of their mattresses features the brand’s Indulge Quilt, which provides that luxury, high-quality feel, that many are looking for. The mattress has an average lifespan of about seven years, as well as a ten-year warranty. These mattresses aren’t cheap, but if you want to sleep luxuriously, they may just be the perfect option for you.

Best Mattresses Under $5,000

Duxiana DUX 1001

9/10

Comfort:

10/10

Pain Relief:

9/10

Durability:

9/10

Warranty:

6/10

Price:

9/10

Overall Score:

 

In a queen size, this bed contains 1,776 innerspring coils. There are two layers of interconnected springs that are designed to provide extra support for the back, shoulders, and legs. With the top support pad, the mattress stands at 12 ¾” tall. The support pad is 2.5” thick and contains latex for support and comfort. Duxiana beds do not contain any harmful chemicals or toxins. It has a 20-year limited warranty.

Duxiana is one of the most high-end mattress brands in the world. With products that are manufactured in Sweden and sold only in select showrooms around the world, this mattress is somewhat difficult to get your hands on, but if you are craving the ultimate luxury in sleep, it just might be worth it.

The bed contains over a thousand small interconnected coils that are designed to move and flex with your body as you sleep. The top pad contains latex foam, which has a flexible, almost bouncy feel that supports your spine and allows for easy movement. The top pad is replaceable, as it is not attached to the base of the mattress.

This bed was designed specifically to target back and neck pain, and testers have found that it does make a difference in these areas. Because of the superior quality materials used in this mattress, it is highly durable.

It is also certified by Oeko Tek 100 for environmentally friendly construction and wear, with no chemicals or toxins that are present in some cheaper mattresses. This is definitely a choice for those who want a very luxurious mattress and requires quite a bit of consideration before purchase. They are only available in certain boutique showrooms throughout the US, so you’ll get to try the mattress out in-store before you buy.

They are only available in certain boutique showrooms throughout the US, so you’ll get to try the mattress out in-store before you buy.

Tempur-Pedic TEMPUR-Cloud Elite Queen Mattress

10/10

Comfort:

10/10

Pain Relief:

8/10

Durability:

7/10

Warranty:

7/10

Price:

8/10

Overall Score:

 

This mattress is 60 x 80 x 12.5 inches and weighs 91 pounds. It is constructed from three layers of memory foam with moisture wicking technology. It has washable and replaceable top cover, and it contains anti-microbial treatment. You can buy matching foundations, mattress protectors, and bed frames directly from Tempur-Pedic to match. It comes with free delivery, a 90-day trial period, and a 10-year limited warranty.

Tempur-Pedic is the original luxury memory foam mattress brand, and they are still a great go-to if you want a high-end memory foam mattress that is really going to support your body and keep you pain-free. The Cloud Elite is on the softer side, but if you prefer a mattress that is slightly firmer, the brand makes similarly priced models at different firmnesses.

The Smart Climate system wicks moisture as you sleep, so it’s perfect for staying cool and dry in a humid climate. The top comfort layer of foam adapts and contours to your body, the middle support layer minimizes motion transfer and evenly distributes your weight, and the base layer expels heat from the bottom of the mattress.

Tempur-Pedic mattresses are highly durable and will last for years to come. Because there are multiple layers of memory foam supporting the body, this minimizes sagging and wear over time. The memory foam also returns to its shape after it has been slept on, which reduces indentations.

Many customers with joint pain particularly love this mattress because it reduces pressure on their back and shoulders while they sleep. This mattress is definitely pricey, and probably best for those who need a medically supportive mattress.

Royal-Pedic All Cotton Mattress

9/10

Comfort:

9/10

Pain Relief:

10/10

Durability:

7/10

Warranty:

7/10

Price:

8.5/10

Overall Score:

 

This mattress is 8” tall, with optional pillowtop pads and box spring to increase the height to 23”. It contains a dense innerspring system with six turn coils and has a classic hand tufted cotton padding and fabric for support. It also has edge supports to help it maintain its structure.

This classic innerspring mattress is one of the most luxurious on the market. The company has a long tradition of making high-quality mattresses from great materials. The spring system has tightly packed six turn coils for support, firmness, and bounce.

The cotton padding on the top is not only soft and comfortable, but it also is very breathable, which provides good ventilation for the mattress and keeps you from sleeping too hot. The mattress runs on the firm side, although they have softer models available in similar constructions.

The mattress is crafted with no chemicals, so there is no off-gassing or unpleasant odors. The cotton padding on top is also healthier for your skin and immune system. The materials are designed for durability, so many Royal Pedic mattresses last for nearly a decade.

You can add additional pillowtop pads to your liking if you need extra support, and you can also buy the matching box spring for the mattress, which also contains expertly crafted coils. The coils in the mattress are separated from the cotton with a thick canvas padding for durability.

Mattress Buyers Q&A

When should you buy a new mattress?

Mattresses are often considered to be an investment, so we don’t often think about when we’ll need to replace them until they are falling apart. However, you should look out for signs of mattress wear and tear regularly so that you can replace your mattress before it becomes completely unusable. Mattresses can have a surprisingly big effect on our health, so it’s very important to make sure that yours is supporting your body comfortably at all times.

The biggest sign that you need to change your mattress is if you often wake up very tired, or you feel pain or muscle tension when you wake up. This means that your mattress is no longer supporting your body adequately.

If your mattress starts to sag or shows visible wear, that’s another good sign that you should start shopping. If you’ve had your mattress for over seven years, that’s also an indicator that you should at least look into a new one, depending on the type of mattress you have and how your body has changed over time.

How does a new mattress help you sleep better?

We all know at least one person who claims they can sleep anywhere. These people may lead us to believe that mattress quality doesn’t affect our ability to sleep, but this is completely untrue. When you buy a new mattress, you’ll likely notice an immediate difference in comfort, which will help you relax and fall asleep faster.

Your old mattress also may have become saggy or uncomfortable over time, making it hard for you to sleep soundly. Even if you didn’t notice yourself waking up throughout the night, constant tossing and turning can interrupt our sleep cycles, leaving you feeling groggy in the morning.

Mattress technology also changes over time, so if you’ve had the same mattress since the ‘90s, the support systems are likely to be pretty outdated. New mattresses are made with well-researched technology to support your back and neck, helping you feel more comfortable as you sleep.

Many modern mattresses also have ventilation and cooling systems, which help regulate your temperature as you sleep. Heat and humidity can be another big problem when it comes to getting enough sleep.

How long will the ‘new mattress’ odor be present?

In the past, many new mattresses took weeks or even months to get rid of that strong, slightly chemical-ish smell that you’re likely familiar with. However, nowaday most mattress companies are aware of this issue and have come up with ways to mitigate the problem.

For traditional memory foam mattresses, you’ll likely need to give them a few days to a week before the smell goes away, but many other mattresses will rid themselves of the smell far more quickly. If you feel like you just can’t get the smell to go away, try stripping your bed, opening your windows, and turning on a fan for a few days to air it out. Be sure to wash your sheets and pillowcases regularly as well to keep your mattress smelling fresh afterward.

What’s the ideal mattress thickness?

There isn’t really one perfect mattress thickness that works for everyone. It’s very dependent on your body shape and structure, as well as your own personal preference. Someone who needs a lot of support and comfort while they sleep will likely feel best on a  mattress that’s over a foot thick, with plenty of layers of memory foam or coil support.

Other sleepers are totally fine on a thinner, denser mattress, which feels light and firm. If you’re heavier, you are going to need a thicker mattress to give you the same feel as a smaller person would feel on a relatively thin mattress. You’ll also need to consider density when choosing a mattress, as a low-density mattress that is very thick could feel similar to a high-density one that is thinner.

How long will my mattress last?

This is another factor that depends on the type of mattress, but generally, mattresses last about ten years at the most. Inexpensive mattresses will likely last for less than five, just because they aren’t made with the same durable materials that higher-end models are.

Some extremely expensive models may be able to last longer than ten years, but you should still re-evaluate your mattress well before you’ve reached that point to ensure that it is still giving you the support you need. Don’t take the warranty as an indicator of how long the mattress will last, either – most mattresses fall apart or lose their shape well before the warranty kicks in.

Are mattresses easy to clean?

It’s very important to keep your mattress clean so that it doesn’t harbor dust mites and bacteria that can make you sick and wear down your immune system. Some of the mattresses that we’ve mentioned in this guide come with covers that are removable and easy to clean, which makes the surface that you sleep on much more sanitary.

You also may want to consider vacuuming your mattress to remove pesky dust mites, as well as using dry baking soda to get rid of odors. You can also use wet baking soda to remove stains. Although mattresses are not always the easiest to clean, these strategies can help you maintain a mattress that is at least sanitary.

How do I dispose of an old mattress?

There are several different ways you can get rid of your mattress. If your mattress is still usable and clean, you may want to consider selling it on Craigslist or to a friend who needs one. This way, you can get a little money back from your investment. However, if your mattress is on the older side, there are some other options you can consider.

Many retailers, such as Amazon, actually offer mattress pickups that will get rid of them for you, without you having to do any work. You may also want to consider donating your old mattress to charity, where it could help those who are in desperate need of a place to sleep. Finally, if your mattress is past the point of being used by anyone, you can always take it to the nearest landfill.

Why should I use a mattress protector?

Many people are skeptical of mattress protectors, but they actually have many benefits for your health and comfort. They absorb many of the fluids that our body gets rid of while we sleep, such as sweat, and prevents other bodily fluids from seeping into the mattress as well.

This keeps them sanitary and healthy. They also keep the mattress in good condition by absorbing the moisture. Even small stains can be very damaging to mattresses, as they wear down the structure of the foam and make them feel less supportive. Although a mattress protector adds a little bit of money to the cost of your mattress, it is definitely a worthwhile investment.

What is the best mattress for a side sleeper?

Side sleepers face unique challenges when choosing a mattress because they are more likely to feel uncomfortable during the night, or develop soreness or aching from pressure points in the mattress. In general, foam mattresses tend to be a better solution for side sleepers, because they conform to your body as you sleep, reducing the pressure points that you might feel with another type of mattress and minimizing pain.

However, everyone has different preferences about how they sleep, so it’s important, especially for side sleepers, to test out the mattress beforehand if possible to determine if it will work for them. Some hybrid and even innerspring mattresses may work well for side sleepers with who prefer a firmer feel, so it’s really a matter of choice and preference.

SHARE
Hey, I'm Lauren, a certified sleep therapist and avid dreamer! I help people to get back to those deep, dream-filled sleeps they remember by helping to identify problems with their routine and bedroom setup.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here